Past Masters of the Lodge
| B. M. Barnett | 1891-1892 |
| David E. Jones | 1893 |
| Solomon J. Jones | 1894 |
| W. D. Mathias | 1895-1896 |
| John Mank | 1897 |
| B. M. Barnett | 1898-1899 |
| George W. Holsinger | 1900 |
| Louis Helmreich | 1901 |
| Henry Mank | 1902 |
| Gerald Holsinger | 1903 |
| William Rankin | 1904 |
| B. M. Barnett | 1905-1906 |
| S. L. Jones | 1907 |
| W. L. Morgan | 1908 |
| William R. Slater | 1909 |
| W. S. Smith | 1910 |
| Marion O Whelan | 1911 |
| George W. Liddle | 1912 |
| Horace S. Woodcock | 1913 |
| Harry Hogan | 1914 |
| Aaron P Vaughn | 1915 |
| Frank G. Rushton | 1916 |
| Louis R. Gates | 1917 |
| James W. Doane | 1918 |
| Gilbert V. Burns | 1919 |
| Howard D. Lawther | 1920 |
| Frank L. Russell | 1921 |
| John B. Smith | 1922 |
| Frank Lobner | 1923 |
| Dean E. Davis | 1924 |
| George G. Jamison | 1925 |
| George A. H. Sturhahn | 1926 |
| Dean E. Davis | 1927 |
| Thomas M. Swinney | 1928 |
| John A. Whitty | 1929 |
| Ray W. Swope | 1930 |
| Benjamin Barnett | 1931 |
| Louis R. Helmreich | 1932 |
| Charles I. McIntyre | 1933 |
| Roy L. Vance | 1934 |
| Chester C. Swager | 1935 |
| Rodney E. Rose | 1936 |
| Forest Glen Cox | 1937 |
| Earl D. Favinger | 1938 |
| William S. Harlan | 1939 |
| George F. Grauberger | 1940 |
| Frank H. Buddemeyer | 1941 |
| Gerald A. Moore | 1942 |
| William J. Rick | 1943 |
| Joseph W. Ellsberry | 1944 |
| Earl D. Favinger | 1945 |
| Cecil E. Eckard | 1946 |
| Bernard Brock | 1947 |
| Woodrow H. Tague | 1948 |
| Warren C. Boydston | 1949 |
| Aron R. Todd | 1950 |
| Robert R. Bates | 1951 |
| Richard T. Frizelle | 1952 |
| Tom R. Hunter | 1953 |
| Smith R. Martin | 1954 |
| Russell G. White | 1955 |
| Harley A. Swope | 1956 |
| Albert O. Arnold Jr. | 1957 |
| Paul C. Ehrig | 1958 |
| Elmer H. Slaven | 1959 |
| Kenneth E. Petty | 1960 |
| Lawrence M. Cinadr | 1961 |
| Carroll D. Fry | 1962 |
| Barney Buchanan Jr. | 1963 |
| Glenn H. Palmer | 1964 |
| Claude F. Smith Jr. | 1965 |
| Ralph D. Hardman Jr. | 1966 |
| Henry F. Higgins | 1967 |
| Paul N. Basham | 1968 |
| Floyd L. Blackwell | 1969 |
| Donald E. Vochatzer | 1970 |
| Floyd C. Hignight | 1971 |
| Carl B. Sherrick | 1972 |
| James S. Prohaska | 1973 |
| J. Eldon Masters | 1974 |
| R. Dennis Kidwell | 1975 |
| Robert E. Williams | 1976 |
| George W. Lawler Jr. | 1977 |
| C. Douglas Jackson | 1978 |
| Alfred L. Geiger | 1979 |
| Burl E. Denton | 1980 |
| William H. Hawkins | 1981 |
| Thomas J. Roy | 1982 |
| Robert E. Williams | 1983 |
| Herold V. Parkes | 1984 |
| Donald Elwood | 1985 |
| Harvey McKinney | 1986 |
| J. Richard Hanson | 1987 |
| Daniel Shelton | 1988 |
| Donald D. West | 1989 |
| Daniel Shelton | 1990 |
| Clyde J. Houston | 1991 |
| Kenneth Kramer | 1992 |
| Bryan West | 1993 |
| Frank Hilgardner | 1994 |
| Robert West | 1995 |
| Donald Cole | 1996 |
| LeRoy Bayless | 1997 |
| Gary Folk | 1998-1999 |
| David Gaunt | 2000 |
| Robert Polsfus | 2001 |
| Roger S. Seigel | 2002 |
| Frank Fuentes | 2003 |
| Terry Sharts | 2004 |
| Dennis Miles | 2005 |
| Troy Zollars | 2006 |
| Barry Pennington | 2007 |
| Darryl King | 2008 |
| Matthew Bailey | 2009 |
| Michael Allen | 2010 |
| Matthew Bailey | 2011 |
| Vernon Chalfant | 2012 |
| Joseph Stubler | 2013-2014 |
| Galen Graves | 2015 |
| Rodger Abbott | 2016 |
| Isaac Pague | 2017 |
| David Hooper | 2018 |
